International Economic Law and Policy Blog
  • Home
  • About
  • WorldTradeLaw.net
Sign in Subscribe

Reply to Prof. Petersmann: Why the end of the Appellate Body must not mean the end of independent third-party adjudication

Dear Ulli, On a slightly more optimistic note than your post of yesterday (and realizing that with corona, other, more important issues are on people's minds), I think you are unnecessarily equating “independent third-party adjudication” with the specific incarnation that the Appellate Body has taken after 25
Joost Pauwelyn 18 Mar 2020 3 min read

SIEL 2020 Conference Postponed  

The following is a notice from SIEL: To the SIEL Community: In light of the evolving situation regarding the COVID-19 crisis, the SIEL Executive Council has decided to postpone the 2020 SIEL Conference, which was schedule to take place in July 2020 at Bocconi University in Milan. We have
Simon Lester 17 Mar 2020 1 min read

Guest Post: WTO ADJUDICATION@me.too: Hidden in plain sight

This is a guest post from Prof. Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, European University Institute Florence Humanity knows from Greek mythology and from the Bible that third-party adjudication emerged and developed in response to never-ending human tragedies (like the pursuit of Orest by the goddesses of revenge punishing Orest’s
Simon Lester 17 Mar 2020 8 min read

Is the Virus Killing Globalization? There’s No One Answer

By Anthea Roberts and Nicolas Lamp Narratives provide the storylines through which people make sense of the world. Actors strategically deploy narratives to advance agendas, telling stories about what or who is to blame and what should be done. When it comes to the coronavirus, multiple narratives are emerging. Instead
Anthea Roberts 16 Mar 2020 1 min read

U.S. "Wins" and "Losses" in WTO Disputes

With Trump complaining about the WTO treating the U.S. unfairly, I get asked now and then about U.S. "wins" and "losses" in WTO disputes. How does the U.S. fare as a complainant and as a respondent? It's a difficult question. A
Simon Lester 15 Mar 2020 3 min read

The UK-EU Trade Talks: The "Level Playing Field"

One of the most controversial aspects of the UK-EU trade talks has to do with the "level playing field." Simplifying things a bit, these are the EU demands that the UK not change its regulation so as to give its producers an advantage over EU competitors. In
Simon Lester 14 Mar 2020 1 min read

EU Proposal on UK-EU Disputes Raising Questions of European Union Law

A version of the EU's proposed "Draft text of the Agreement on the New Partnership between the European Union and the United Kingdom" is available here (this may be a leaked version, with some edits before an official one is published). There's a lot
Simon Lester 14 Mar 2020 2 min read

It Sure Looks Different from the Inside, and Now the Outside Too? (or "Graham on Graham")

Simon Lester's posts about Tom Graham's recent speech on the Appellate Body ("AB") reminded me the speech Graham gave back in 2013, which was "[s]oon after [he] joined the Appellate Body". When I re-read the 2013 speech entitled "It
Henry Gao 11 Mar 2020 5 min read

Tom Graham's Full Speech on the Appellate Body

Last week, I posted about the Inside US Trade summary of Tom Graham's remarks on the Appellate Body (entitled "The Rise (and Demise?) of the WTO Appellate Body"). I now have the full text, which is here. Here is one part: Soon after I joined the
Simon Lester 09 Mar 2020 1 min read

The Trump Administration's Shameful Attack on Appellator Zhao

The Trump Administration's Shameful Attack on Appellator Zhao 5 March 2020 Steve Charnovitz On 5 February 2020, I posted a paper, <https://ielp.worldtradelaw.net/2020/02/the-illegitimate-ab-report-in-russia-railway-equipment-.html>, explaining why the Appellate Body's February 3 decision
Charnovitz 05 Mar 2020 3 min read

About

International Economic Law and Policy Blog

International Economic Law and Policy Blog

Expert commentary on the law, politics and economics of international trade and investment

Sign up for email notifications

jamie@example.com
Subscribe

Featured

Does The EU Need Its Own Section 301 To Counter China's Distortions?

Recently, economists Sander Tordoir and Brad Setser suggested that the EU may need its own version of Section 301 in order to "confront China’s systemic distortions beyond piecemeal trade defence."
17 Jun 2026 7 min read

The Section 301 Forced Labor Import Ban Report

On June 2, 2026, USTR released its report on its Section 301 investigation into acts, policies, and practices of various economies related to the failure to impose and effectively enforce a prohibition on the importation of goods produced with forced labor.
04 Jun 2026 11 min read

What To Expect from the USMCA Review?

The USMCA review is almost upon us. How exactly things will proceed is a bit unclear, as we've never done this sort of thing before, but July 1 is the six year anniversary of the USMCA's entry into force.
03 Jun 2026 15 min read

China in the World Trading System: A Response to Chad, and Some Comments on Froman-Greer

I'm going to use this post to (1) respond to Chad and (2) comment on an exchange between current U.S. Trade Rep. Jamieson Greer and former U.S. Trade Rep. Mike Froman at a recent CFR event.
01 Jun 2026 7 min read

My Response To Simon on China in the World Trading System

Here are two quick reactions to the super important question of what explains why countries did not use WTO dispute settlement to push China to change.
28 May 2026 2 min read

Topics

2008 Presidential Election

25 posts

2012 Republican Primary

6 posts

2020 Democratic Primary

22 posts

2020 Presidential Campaign

6 posts

2024 Presidential Campaign

9 posts

2024 Republican Primary

9 posts

Announcements

27 posts

Appellate Body

72 posts

CAFTA

5 posts

CETA

8 posts

Currency Disputes

57 posts

Development

23 posts

Digital Trade

59 posts

Domestic Trade Powers

10 posts

Dormant Commerce Clause

3 posts

DSU 25 Interim Appeals

43 posts

DSU Article 11

13 posts

Economic Integration

8 posts

Economic Statecraft

10 posts

EU-UK Trade Negotiation

5 posts

Exceptions

19 posts

Exchange Rates

6 posts

Export Restrictions

13 posts

Food Aid

5 posts

Foreign Investment

21 posts

FTA Negotiations

13 posts

FTAs - General

22 posts

Gambling Dispute

52 posts

Global Governance

9 posts

Globalization

13 posts

Government Procurement

5 posts

Green Steel Deal

14 posts

IEEPA

9 posts

IEL in Domestic Courts

20 posts

Indo-Pacific Economic Framework

5 posts

Industrial Policy

20 posts

Investor-State Arbitration

93 posts

Jamieson Greer

19 posts

Katherine Tai

66 posts

NAFTA

19 posts

NAFTA Chapter 11

15 posts

NAFTA Chapter 19

5 posts

National Security

38 posts

Non Appeal Pact

3 posts

Non-Discrimination Standards

60 posts

Non-Market Economies

7 posts

Non-Violation Nullification or Impairment

19 posts

Precedent

25 posts

Public Views of Trade

9 posts

Rare Earths

1 post

Robert Lighthizer

18 posts

Russia Trade Sanctions

17 posts

Sanctions

15 posts

Section 301

14 posts

Sovereignty

9 posts

Speech

1 post

SPS/TBT

5 posts

Standards of Review

7 posts

State Enterprises

8 posts

Sub-National Trade Issues

5 posts

Subsidies

83 posts

Tariffs

3 posts

Terms of Trade Manipulation

6 posts

Trade Agreements

21 posts

Trade and Competition

14 posts

Trade and Development

21 posts

Trade and Environment

119 posts

Trade and Health

20 posts

Trade and Human Rights

9 posts

Trade and Income Inequality

1 post

Trade and Intellectual Property

26 posts

Trade and Labor

26 posts

Trade and Peace

4 posts

Trade and Security

35 posts

Trade and the Stock Market

2 posts

Trade Balance

13 posts

Trade in Everything

65 posts

Trade in Services

21 posts

Trade Law and International Law

10 posts

Trade Preferences/GSP

23 posts

Trade Remedies

64 posts

Trans Pacific Partnership

9 posts

Trump Administration

55 posts

U.S. Trade Policy

32 posts

U.S. Trade Politics

60 posts

US-China Trade Relations

28 posts

USMCA

19 posts

USMCA Dispute Settlement

34 posts

USMCA Sunset/Review Clause

24 posts

USTR

16 posts

WTO - General

25 posts

WTO Accessions

8 posts

WTO Disputes

177 posts

WTO DS Reform

13 posts

WTO Jurisprudence

28 posts

WTO Negotiations

30 posts
Powered by Ghost