The U.S. appellant's submission is here: http://www.ustr.gov/webfm_send/3225 Here's one issue I'll be watching during the appeal:
73. In reaching its conclusion that Section 907(a)(1)(A) accords less favorable treatment to imported clove cigarettes than to like domestic products, the Panel erred in several respects. First, the Panel erred in its interpretation of which products should be compared. The Panel Report compares only the treatment accorded to Indonesian clove cigarettes and to domestic menthol cigarettes, and fails to compare the treatment accorded to like imported products, as a group, with that accorded to like domestic products, as a group. ...
